Pine Island Heating Oil Prices
11 suppliers · Updated June 3, 2026
$4.45
Average
$4.24
Lowest
$0.41
Potential Savings
Compare Suppliers
| Supplier | Location | Price/Gal | Phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Affordable Fuel Delivery | Modena | $4.24 | (845) 883-0194 | Website |
| Wilson Fuel Co. | Montague | $4.65 | (973) 293-3807 | Website |
| Big O Fuels | Middletown | Call | (845) 733-1930 | Website |
| Combined Energy Services | Monticello | Call | (845) 794-1210 | Website |
| Diamond Petroleum | Washingtonville | Call | (845) 496-4646 | Website |
| Emergency Services Fuel Corp | Briarcliff Manor | Call | (914) 762-5208 | |
| Forno Fuel | Montrose | Call | (914) 877-1115 | Website |
| Fredericks Fuel | Oak Ridge | Call | (973) 841-6191 | Website |
| Miller Energy | Chester | Call | (845) 341-3108 | Website |
| Panco Petroleum | Goshen | Call | (800) 477-4645 | Website |
| Quinn Oil | Goshen | Call | (845) 291-1961 | Website |
Prices shown are reported by suppliers. Actual delivered prices may vary by volume and payment method. Always confirm when ordering.
Never Run Out of Oil
HomeHeat tracks your usage and predicts when you'll need your next delivery — no sensors required.
Get HomeHeat Free → Save HomeHeat to Your Phone →Other Cities in Orange County
Find prices in your exact area
Enter your ZIP code for suppliers that deliver to your address.
Check My ZIP Code →