Average Heating Bill in New York → Sullivan County
$612/mo
$3,674/year
$1.84/sq ft (oil heat, 2,000 sq ft home)
↓ Oil prices are down 3.7% over the past 6 weeks, which affects current heating bills. View price trends.
| Fuel | Local Price | Cost/MMBTU | Annual Cost | Monthly (Heating) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Natural Gas Cheapest | $2.04/therm | $22 | $2,118 | $353 |
| Heat Pump | $0.29/kWh | $29 | $2,778 | $463 |
| Heating Oil | $4.48/gallon | $38 | $3,674 | $612 |
| Electric Baseboard | $0.29/kWh | $86 | $8,335 | $1,389 |
Cheapest option for this area
Natural Gas
$2,118/year estimated — saving $1,556/year vs heating oil
Average monthly heating costs during the October–March season for a 2,000 sq ft home in Sullivan County:
Based on a 2,000 sq ft home with 85% oil furnace efficiency, COP 3.0 heat pump, NOAA 30-year normal heating degree days (6,898 HDD for Sullivan County), and current EIA state-average energy rates. Oil prices reflect local median from 5 tracked suppliers.
Data updated 2026-07-18.
Track price drops and predict your next delivery with the HomeHeat app.
Get HomeHeat Free →Free app for iPhone. No hardware. No ads.
If you're staying with oil heat, compare local suppliers to find the best price. The spread in Sullivan County can be $0.50–$1.00/gallon.
Median: $4.48/gal · 5 suppliers reporting prices
Compare Sullivan County Suppliers →We'll email you when local heating oil prices drop to your target — no spam, only price drops.